Outbreak of World War II in Europe
The Plot Against AmericaThe Outbreak of World War II in Europe, which began in September 1939, supplies the international crisis against which the novel measures American neutrality, isolationism, and escalating political division. Its significance lies not only in the war abroad but in the choices it sharpens at home: whether the United States should remain outside the conflict, and how the language of neutrality could coexist with growing domestic support for authoritarian politics.
The European War and American Neutrality
By September 1941, two years after the war began, Charles A. Lindbergh described the United States as standing on the verge of war. In a speech at a rally of the America First Committee in Des Moines, he argued that foreign interests and a minority of Americans had steadily pressed the country toward involvement. He presented the shift away from neutrality and independence as a question of responsibility: who had brought the nation so close to entanglement in European affairs? His address makes the outbreak a continuing political reference point rather than a distant event; the conflict’s duration becomes evidence in an argument over the country’s future course.
The chronology also establishes the war’s third winter as an approaching threshold. Lindbergh’s account is a political interpretation of the crisis, not a neutral description of the forces driving it. The novel places that interpretation alongside the consequences of the American policy debate, allowing the rhetoric of non-intervention to be read against the increasingly volatile politics unfolding within the United States.
Isolationism and Its Political Alliance
In the novel’s historical chronology, Henry Ford joined his friend Lindbergh in supporting isolationism and the America First Committee as war broke out in Europe. Ford’s appointment to the committee’s executive body had an immediate political consequence: Lessing J. Rosenwald, the Jewish director of Sears, Roebuck and Company, resigned because of Ford’s antisemitic reputation. The episode shows that isolationism was not merely a position on foreign policy. Its public alliances affected who could participate in the movement and how its leadership was understood.
Ford’s association with other prominent antisemites further complicates the movement’s claim to speak for national independence. He met regularly for a time with Father Coughlin, whose activities Franklin D. Roosevelt and Harold L. Ickes believed Ford was financing, and supported Gerald L. K. Smith’s radio broadcasts and living expenses. These details do not make the European outbreak the sole cause of domestic antisemitism; they show how the crisis coincided with, and gave political force to, networks already active in American public life.
The Domestic Political Crisis
In the novel’s later account of the American crisis, Walter Winchell’s congressional campaign turns opposition to Lindbergh’s government into street-corner speech. Beginning in New York after Labor Day, Winchell drew crowds with denunciations of fascism and continued his campaign through other cities. In Boston, a gathering that began with heckling escalated into an assault; the local police did not intervene promptly, and Winchell’s bodyguards took him to Carney Hospital for treatment. The scene marks a shift from political argument to organized violence, but the evidence presents it as part of the novel’s American political crisis, not as a direct consequence of the European outbreak alone.
After violence in Detroit, Newark’s Jewish community prepared for the possibility of attacks in its own streets. Rabbi Joachim Prinz and other prominent residents formed the Newark Committee of Concerned Jewish Citizens and sought contingency plans with city and state authorities. Separately, Longy Zwillman tasked Bullet Apfelbaum with recruiting and training a volunteer corps, the Provisional Jewish Police, in case the police and state authorities failed to protect the community. These parallel efforts—appeals through civic institutions and preparations for neighborhood self-defense—show how political conflict entered the practical arrangements of daily life.
The escalation reaches a further point when a radio bulletin announces that Winchell has been killed at a political rally in Louisville by a suspected American Nazi Party assassin working with the Ku Klux Klan. The bulletin is heard in the Roth family’s kitchen, interrupting Herman Roth’s speech about the danger facing his family and fellow citizens. The novel thus sets an international war debate beside a domestic emergency in which political violence threatens the rights and safety of American Jews.
Significance in the Novel
The outbreak anchors competing definitions of patriotism. Lindbergh’s account treats the pressure to enter the war as a threat to American independence; the events at home expose the danger of treating neutrality as separate from the country’s internal political struggle. Ford’s alliance with Lindbergh, the resignation of Rosenwald, Winchell’s campaign, and Newark’s preparations each disclose a different consequence of that struggle, without reducing them to a single cause.
The event is therefore both a chronological marker and a frame for political disagreement. Two years after the European war began, Lindbergh’s speech insists that the United States is approaching a decisive choice. The novel’s later scenes test that claim against the violence, civic organizing, and fear already present within the country.